S StarSoaper New Member Joined Dec 13, 2013 Messages 4 Reaction score 0 Dec 30, 2013 #1 I just made a honey and oatmeal soap and I believe it overheated ._. It was a pretty light orange color and then it started to get dark brown with slightly grey edges. I didn't put a lid on it. Is it still usable? How can I prevent overheating?