I made my first batch, using a tried and true recipe from a famous book. The only thing I changed was the water for aloe juice. I didn't have distilled water and I had the juice, so I thought it would work it out.
After 24 hours (more like 30), it looked dry enough, so I took it off the mold and when I went to cut it, it was still sticky, getting stuck in the knife. Last night (2 days later), still soft-ish.
My question is....what should I do now? Discard the batch completely? Take it off the mold to air-dry (It's in a ziplock container w/ the cover)? Rebatch?
Any info will be hugely appreciated.