akseattle
Well-Known Member
I’m was very excited to have made my first batch of cold process soap on Saturday 1/6!
But, now I’m super bummed and feel like I’m waiting to hear the repair cost for a fender bender. I wanted a hard and moisturizing bar- so I found one online by OffTheGrid. I halved her recipe but didn’t put it through the lye calculator cuz she said “Don’t be tempted to fiddle with the recipe because it won’t work.” So, I didn’t. Until this morning. She didn’t say what superfat it had, so I randomly put in 3%. The first thing I noticed was that I had remarkably less liquid than the lye calculator showed.
I adjusted the superfat as high as 10% (where the calculator ends) and I am still nowhere in the ballpark.
I went back to OffTheGrid and I have zero idea where I got my numbers! The first column is what I used, then what her recipe called for, and the third, what I wrote down as her recipe.
180 g. olive oil (OffTG wrote- 450 g) - ( I wrote down 50% of 360 g )
112.5 g. coconut oil (OffTG wrote- 180 g) (I wrote down 50% of 225 g)
112.5 g. shea butter (OffTG wrote- 180 g) (I wrote down 50% of 225g)
45 g. castor oil (OffTG wrote- 90 g) (I got the 90 g of castor oil right ….)
80 g. water (OffTG wrote 315 g) ( I wrote down 50% of 160 g)
62 g. lye (OffTG wrote 122 g) (I got the 122 g of lye right .. )
Off the Grid didn’t use colorants and made no recommendation on essential oil- just said, put in a little if you want it mild, put in more if you want it stronger. I used coconut E.O. which is pretty mild. To be safe, I didn’t put in too much. I was going for a white, beige & bronze bar (had one of my sons in mind for this soap- he has really dry skin & I thought the high level of shea butter would be perfect.) Even doubling the Diamond White mica, it was only lightening the yellow batter, so accepted that. The Olive green which has always made beige in my white M&P, was actually closer to the grey green that it is supposed to produce (not my intent for this soap.) But, I accepted that, too. I was really going with the flow! My only real deviation was that I added espresso grinds as an exfoliant to the grey batter ( and sprinkled it on top of one) in addition to adding micas.
Everything I read said that you can unmold soap made in single cavity molds sooner than a loaf. But, literally, I unmolded this 5 hours after pouring. Even though the colors weren’t what I had in mind, I was actually pretty excited and already thinking of my next CP project. I showed it to my son. He liked it and was bummed when I said it had to cure for another 6+ weeks (he leaves for India in a month.) But, I told him he can take it and let it cure on the road.
I couldn't help myself and peeked at my soap a couple times yesterday-- partially marveling that I had finally gotten up my courage to try CP soap, but really wondering about when the parade of horribles could start to happen – soda ash, glycerin rivers, cracking…
My soap still looks fine. I remember being surprised by how little water I was measuring out but decided to trust the recipe. I don't know if I’m using the lye calculator correctly, but my recipe - having been completely bungled-- has a serious shortage of liquid.
I hate to be a Debbie Downer, but What can I expect? And when can I expect these things to happen?
But, now I’m super bummed and feel like I’m waiting to hear the repair cost for a fender bender. I wanted a hard and moisturizing bar- so I found one online by OffTheGrid. I halved her recipe but didn’t put it through the lye calculator cuz she said “Don’t be tempted to fiddle with the recipe because it won’t work.” So, I didn’t. Until this morning. She didn’t say what superfat it had, so I randomly put in 3%. The first thing I noticed was that I had remarkably less liquid than the lye calculator showed.
I adjusted the superfat as high as 10% (where the calculator ends) and I am still nowhere in the ballpark.
I went back to OffTheGrid and I have zero idea where I got my numbers! The first column is what I used, then what her recipe called for, and the third, what I wrote down as her recipe.
180 g. olive oil (OffTG wrote- 450 g) - ( I wrote down 50% of 360 g )
112.5 g. coconut oil (OffTG wrote- 180 g) (I wrote down 50% of 225 g)
112.5 g. shea butter (OffTG wrote- 180 g) (I wrote down 50% of 225g)
45 g. castor oil (OffTG wrote- 90 g) (I got the 90 g of castor oil right ….)
80 g. water (OffTG wrote 315 g) ( I wrote down 50% of 160 g)
62 g. lye (OffTG wrote 122 g) (I got the 122 g of lye right .. )
Off the Grid didn’t use colorants and made no recommendation on essential oil- just said, put in a little if you want it mild, put in more if you want it stronger. I used coconut E.O. which is pretty mild. To be safe, I didn’t put in too much. I was going for a white, beige & bronze bar (had one of my sons in mind for this soap- he has really dry skin & I thought the high level of shea butter would be perfect.) Even doubling the Diamond White mica, it was only lightening the yellow batter, so accepted that. The Olive green which has always made beige in my white M&P, was actually closer to the grey green that it is supposed to produce (not my intent for this soap.) But, I accepted that, too. I was really going with the flow! My only real deviation was that I added espresso grinds as an exfoliant to the grey batter ( and sprinkled it on top of one) in addition to adding micas.
Everything I read said that you can unmold soap made in single cavity molds sooner than a loaf. But, literally, I unmolded this 5 hours after pouring. Even though the colors weren’t what I had in mind, I was actually pretty excited and already thinking of my next CP project. I showed it to my son. He liked it and was bummed when I said it had to cure for another 6+ weeks (he leaves for India in a month.) But, I told him he can take it and let it cure on the road.
I couldn't help myself and peeked at my soap a couple times yesterday-- partially marveling that I had finally gotten up my courage to try CP soap, but really wondering about when the parade of horribles could start to happen – soda ash, glycerin rivers, cracking…
My soap still looks fine. I remember being surprised by how little water I was measuring out but decided to trust the recipe. I don't know if I’m using the lye calculator correctly, but my recipe - having been completely bungled-- has a serious shortage of liquid.
I hate to be a Debbie Downer, but What can I expect? And when can I expect these things to happen?