Dubnica,
What were your starting temps and how thickly did you trace? Your oils are mostly 'soft' oils, with the exception of the Crisco because it is part Palm oil - even then it is not what I would personally call a 'hard' oil. Usually it is the 'hard' oils that get a little bonkers in the temperature department.
My advice:
1. Soap cool - Make your lye water ahead of time and let it cool to room temp. Then melt your crisco over low heat until it just goes from cloudy to clear. Add that to the other oils (which are at room temp and have NOT been heated).
2. Thin trace - the thicker you trace, the faster you get the reaction happening, the hotter it is going to get. Just be careful you don't get a false trace or tooo thin of a trace or you may get a separating, oily, caustic mess.
3. Pre-freeze your molds if they are wood. PrairieCraft hit the nail on the head - wood is an extremely good insulator, so it will keep the heat in that is generated during saponification. Line your molds and put them in the freezer for a full 2 hours before you soap.
4. Freeze first, then fridge. Cover your soap *only* with plastic wrap or freezer paper - NO lids. Put them in the freezer for an hour (or two!!), then move to the fridge overnight.
5. Let the soapsicles thaw completely on the counter before unmolding - you don't want to have condensation on your new soap! Note this will take about half a day.
6. Be aware that your ungelled soaps are going to be much softer at first.
Better luck on the next batch!
-Chris