Alchemy&Ashes said:
Well, I think that your dilution is a little high (8.5 oz Infusion to 5.5oz Liquid Soap), but also, Castille soap isn't a highly cleansing soap (hence the advocated use for sensitive skin) so any dilution is going to kill what little lather you get and not feel as "clean" afterwards.
You could try a decoction of your herbs (a stronger brew, usually heating or boiling depending on your herb, then cooked down to a concentrate) with a higher soap to decoction ratio. I would do no more than 2 parts Soap to 1 part Herbal Infusion/Decoction.
You could also use essential oils instead your herbal infusion...what herbs are you using?
Or, if you want to actually make CP or HP soap, there's oils you could use to make it more cleansing (like Coconut and whatever oil you choose, plus 20% Castor and a higher superfat) and still use your herbs. I would infuse one of my soap making oils with the herbs I want to use. If I was concerned that the herb wouldn't make it through the whole saponification process, I would HP and add the infusion at the end of the cook.
What's funny is that my ratio is greater towards the soap than my natural body care recipes have recommended to me.
I have added more soap to the recipe, and have had varying degrees of success, but I'm stubborn, and want to figure this out!
My herbal recipe is quite diverse, as I used the recipe that Stephanie Tourles came up with for her book Natural Body Care, and then I just increased the quantities of herbs, and then started adding herbs that I have around that I had wanted to use up that seemed like they would work well in the recipe. Here's my recipe, the herbs are all dried:
3 Tablespoons Calendula blossoms
3 Tablespoons Chamomile flowers
1 1/2 Tablespoons Comfrey root
1 1/2 Tablespoons Orange peel
2 Tablespoons Nettle leaf
1 teaspoon Hibiscus flowers (as an experiment)
1 teaspoon Lavender flowers
! tablespoon Rosemary
1 tablespoon Comfrey leaf
1 1/2 tablespoons Rose petals
I boiled 2 cups of water and poured that over the herbs, and stirred. Then I realized that my free handedness in trying to make the infusion as strong as possible backfired on me, as I had to boil more water to get the herbs sufficiently submerged to be able to steep properly. I think I added another cup of liquid. I then left it overnight, covered, and strained the next morning. I froze the excess, and plan on boiling it down in a covered pot to try and preserve as much of the essential oils as possible, once I'm out of the current batch.
I still haven't made any soap yet, the thought of using lye when my baby is awake is a little nerve wracking to me. But I've been reading up on it for a couple of years, and wondered about making homemade shampoos with herbal infused oils. But I had wanted to find out before I experiment whether my idea would even work.
Cheers!