Pinetar sloooww...to trace???

Soapmaking Forum

Help Support Soapmaking Forum:

Joined
Mar 24, 2020
Messages
472
Reaction score
1,126
Location
NewHampshire
Hi everybody,
Another batch pinetar soap. No color, no fragrance. Just straight up pinetar. My original batch stayed pourable. For a reasonable amount of time. But this batch just did not want to trace.

The recipe:
OO 40%
CO 20%
Lard 40%
Pinetar 10% (Bickmore Brand)
Cocoa Butr 5%
Castor oil 5%

All ingredients are fresh, only sub lard for palm. (Same Percentage)

Process:
Combined lye solution with soft oils. Bring to light trace. ( never got there, last patience)
Added hard oils, pinetar second. (At this stage, it's usually Pour, Pour, pour! !!)

Finally after 20-25 minutes. It started to noticeably trace. Made sure it wasn't separated. Throughout the entire time. My biggest worry. Then poured. Now I'm not complaining.
Just passing this along. Pinetar that took forever to trace? Soaped around 100 Fahrenheit. Lye room temperature.

received_544843127398559.jpeg

Almost forgot, no stick blender used.
 
Joined
Nov 15, 2018
Messages
8,421
Reaction score
15,108
Location
US
I made pine tar soap recently and also didn't stick-blend at first. I actually melted all the oils together, including the pine tar, and then added my room-temp lye solution. It simply would not come to trace with hand-whisking alone. But after one tiny burst with the SB, it was pudding for one second, and then semi-solid soap that had to be pounded into the mold. It was mostly smooth but had a few air pockets, for sure.

Yours looks great - like fudge. 😋
 

Zany_in_CO

Saponifier
Joined
Mar 9, 2017
Messages
8,629
Reaction score
9,579
Location
SE Denver CO
Soaped around 100 Fahrenheit. Lye room temperature.
Almost forgot, no stick blender used.
10 10 10.gif

I think you have discovered the secret to making Pine Tar Soap that doesn't seize! The picture is clear evidence of that. Lovely soap. Well done!
 

earlene

Grandmother & Soaper
Supporting Member
Joined
Apr 30, 2016
Messages
9,781
Reaction score
11,980
Location
Western Illinois, USA
Gorgeously smooth looking pinetar soap, @Ford.

Judging by your experience and @AliOop's experience, it looks like hand stirring is one clue but IMO not the only one. I also have made pine tar soap without a stick blender, and did not have the same experience as either or you. So there are other factors at work, such as brand of pine tar, temperature, recipe and also process differences.

So I do believe your recipe (including brand of pine tar), temperatures, and possibly certain steps within your process also contributed to this slowing of trace.

But I do have a couple of questions:

Were your hard oils pre-melted and cooled down to your RT (I think yes, but just to be sure)? Did you attempt to reach trace after adding the hard oils or did you add the pine tar immediately after adding the hard oils? I wasn't clear on that in your process description.

Recipe factors to consider: Lard slows to trace, so hand stirring a recipe with 40% lard also contributed to slowing trace, particularly if you normally make pine tar soap with palm rather than lard.

For me, the brand was Farnam's Horse Health pine tar, which is very very thick (see first video below), also my temperatures were different because I heated the pine tar to soften it before adding to the soap batter (after trace), and of course our recipes did differ, not only in oils (a little bit), but perhaps in water content as well.

From what I see & read, Bickmore pinetar is pourable from the can (see 2nd video below), whereas the brand I use is very thick and stiff and cannot be poured from the can without first softening with heat. Some soapers heat the pine tar with the hard oils to melt & combine them all in one step, which would contribute to faster trace. I have not tried heating pine tar with the oils prior to adding the lye solution, so don't have experience with what that is like.

Another possible difference between your process & mine is likely room temperature. Comfortable RT varies between households, personal preference, seasons, climate, etc. So if I add that room temperature difference to my pre-warmed pine tar, there are potentially 2 temperature differences playing a role in trace time.

Below are 3 youtube videos on no-SB pine tar soap. These links show the consistency of 3 brands of pine tar in their the original containers starting a the spot where the consistency of that particular brand is clearly visible. I suspect this difference of consistency may also affect speed of trace.

Farnam Horse Health brand pine tar


Bickmore brand pine tar


Stockholm brand tar
 

tyerod

Well-Known Member
Joined
Dec 10, 2012
Messages
85
Reaction score
52
Location
Colorado
I am intrigued by the long time before it traced. I am going to have to try a batch without using a stick blender. I have used the Horse Health brand and American Rope & Tar brand PT and it has always been a rush to get it in a mold before it completely seized up.
 
Joined
Nov 15, 2018
Messages
8,421
Reaction score
15,108
Location
US
I experienced that until I followed the process (although not the recipe) from Ellie's Everyday YT (video was posted above). I melted and mixed all oils and the pine tar together; they were probably at 100-110F. Then I added my room temp MB lye solution, which had some additional water with dissolved sodium citrate, which immediately caused the lye solution to start warming up. The combined batter was probably 95-100F when I began to stir it all with a whisk. This was a high-tallow recipe, and it did not want to emulsify even after minutes of whisking. But a one-second burst with the stickblender made it go from separated to pudding, to almost solid. I'd like to get smoother results, so I may try again and just let it sit for a bit between bouts of whisking.
 
Last edited:
Joined
Mar 24, 2020
Messages
472
Reaction score
1,126
Location
NewHampshire
Hi, no claims here. Just passing on my observations. Hoping others may learn. This is only my second batch of pinetar. So I was surprised
when it did not trace as quickly as before. Used this recipe for the first batch. But did swap out the palm (no stir) for lard. So yes that would contribute
to slow the trace. Ambient temps in my cellar this time of year run about 65-70. My pine tar was added to the hard oils prior to adding to the soft oil, lye solution mix. The process I found online. In a video. Hope this helps. Thanks again.
The recipe:
OO 40%
CO 20%
Lard 20%
Pine tar 10% (Bickmore Brand)
Cocoa Butter 5%
Castor oil 5%
 

Marsi

Well-Known Member
Joined
Apr 18, 2020
Messages
555
Reaction score
1,027
Location
australia
... and of course our recipes did differ, not only in oils (a little bit), but perhaps in water content as well.
Ford and AliOop, what lye concentration did you use?
(I wonder if this has contributed to the slower trace?)

Thanks for sharing Ford - I like your pine tar soap!
 

Marsi

Well-Known Member
Joined
Apr 18, 2020
Messages
555
Reaction score
1,027
Location
australia
It's not the water then ...
So far, the two things you have in common are adding the pine tar to the oils and hand whisking.
I'm going to have to try this! 🥰
 
Top