untraced soap?

Advertise with us
Soapmaking Forum

Help Support Soapmaking Forum:

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.
DaKakashi

DaKakashi

Member
Joined
Nov 6, 2014
Messages
9
Reaction score
8
hey guys, I have a question. Yesterday when I was tracing my soap, my stick blender stopped working. I tried to continue to mix it with a hand mixer, but my soap couldn't get to trace, or had a really light trace. All the ingredients were mixed together, nothing was separating, and it wasn't so liquid, but I continued to blend and nothing happened. finally I decided to pour it into the mold and see what happened.
Today I checked the soap, and it harden up and was warm like a normal soap.
does somebody know what happened? this is the third time that I use this recipe, I never had this problem before. I used the exact same ingredients, and I didn't mix in the essential oils when it happened. are the soaps usable? can an untraced soap harden-up like a normal one, or i did get to a really light trace?
thanks very much for your help, and i'm sorry if I my english is bad, its not my native language :oops:
 
When you get to trace, whether it's light trace, medium trace, heavy trace, you can mold it. If it hardened, it got to trace. If it separated, then it didn't. Test it to see if it's lye heavy. If it's not, then you have perfectly good soap.

I don't know what your recipe is but certain factors like temperature, amount of water, fragrance, speed of blending, etc. can affect how quickly the soap traces.
 
thanks for the quick answers! I already cut the soap into pieces and it looks amazing. now I only have to find another stick blender lol
 
A stick blender is actually not an absolute necessity. You can soap without one (I myself still make certain batches without one....on purpose), but it sure does make things a whole lot easier and quicker. I Just thought I'd let you know that in case you were thinking that one can't ever make soap without one.

When you go to zap test your soap, don't do it right away after unmolding and cutting. Wait about a week or so and then test. I say that because it's not uncommon to get a false positive zap so early on. I let mine sit at least 7 days before zap-testing.

IrishLass :)
 
Agree with IrishLass. My first few soap batches were made by handmixing. But it just took too long to get it to trace. (There was once I had to handmix for more than an hour to get it to very light trace. I gave up and dumped it into the mold so I got myself a stick blender to spare myself the grief)
 
cmzaha said:
Actually soap batter only needs to get to emulsification. When no oil floats to the top of your batter it can be poured with or without a trace. It will just take longer to set up
Click to expand...

^^
i second this. a proper emulsification is all you need. and i think you've proven this with the current batch in question.

personally, i don't like to go till thick trace. i usually pour as soon as it hits the lightest trace.
 
IrishLass said:
A stick blender is actually not an absolute necessity. You can soap without one (I myself still make certain batches without one....on purpose), but it sure does make things a whole lot easier and quicker. I Just thought I'd let you know that in case you were thinking that one can't ever make soap without one.

When you go to zap test your soap, don't do it right away after unmolding and cutting. Wait about a week or so and then test. I say that because it's not uncommon to get a false positive zap so early on. I let mine sit at least 7 days before zap-testing.

IrishLass :)
Click to expand...
How long it takes you to mix one batch and is there a spicific reason to do that?
 
Last edited:
hud said:
How long it takes you to mix one batch and is there a spicific reason to do that?
Click to expand...

With the batches that I don't use a stick-blender, I'm working with a very fast-moving FO, and so I only stir by hand or by whisk to keep things from getting out of hand. If I used a stick-blender in those particular batches, I would probably end up with soap-on-a-stick faster than you could say, 'Uh-oh'. lol

IrishLass :)
 
IrishLass said:
With the batches that I don't use a stick-blender, I'm working with a very fast-moving FO, and so I only stir by hand or by whisk to keep things from getting out of hand. If I used a stick-blender in those particular batches, I would probably end up with soap-on-a-stick faster than you could say, 'Uh-oh'. lol

IrishLass :)
Click to expand...

I thought about this, too.
Very smart as usual.:razz:
 
Emulsification

I cannot tell you how happy I was to read that it's OK to pour at emulsification! Watching so many soap making videos closely, and repeatedly, it sure looked like they weren't pouring at trace!

One question about light trace that came up for my yesterday, was when two people mentioned paisley in relation to trace. What is paisley?????? I know what paisley designs are in fabric, etc. but what does the term mean in soap making?

So much to learn!

June
 
When you swirl your SB around in your soap pot, you will often see paisley like designs on the surface of the batter that disappear after a few seconds.

A zap test is a way to test if your soap is lye heavy. Once your soap is 2-3 days old, wet a finger tip and lightly rub it across the soap then touch it to the tip of your tongue. If it gives you a zap, it still has active lye, if it doesn't then the soap is safe.
 
Stick blenders are very nice for soaping, but my grandmother made lye soap by stirring with a big kitchen spoon and having a lot of patience. :)

I do not use a stick blender if I am making pine tar soap or (like Irish Lass) if I use a fragrance that causes the soap to emulsify quickly. In those cases, I just use my version of Grandma's big kitchen spoon.
 
SoapinInAl said:
What does it mean to zap test?
Click to expand...

If you touch the soap to your tongue and get a slight zap, think touching a 9 volt battery to your tongue, then it's still not finished processing the lye or your soap is lye heavy.

On CP soap, you shouldn't be getting a zap after max of 2 days. Mine exhibits no zap in 24 hours max. It doesn't mean the soap is done, it still needs to "cure", but it shows the soap is safe. No leftover lye.
 
DaKakashi said:
hey guys, I have a question. Yesterday when I was tracing my soap, my stick blender stopped working. I tried to continue to mix it with a hand mixer, but my soap couldn't get to trace, or had a really light trace. All the ingredients were mixed together, nothing was separating, and it wasn't so liquid, but I continued to blend and nothing happened. finally I decided to pour it into the mold and see what happened.
Today I checked the soap, and it harden up and was warm like a normal soap.
does somebody know what happened? this is the third time that I use this recipe, I never had this problem before. I used the exact same ingredients, and I didn't mix in the essential oils when it happened. are the soaps usable? can an untraced soap harden-up like a normal one, or i did get to a really light trace?
thanks very much for your help, and i'm sorry if I my english is bad, its not my native language :oops:
Click to expand...

:) I think you did a great job explaining yourself, and your English is just fine!
 
JustBeachy said:
On CP soap, you shouldn't be getting a zap after max of 2 days.
Click to expand...

.............unless you have a stubborn, ornery (or maybe just a 'slow-as-molasses' to react) un-gelled batch of soap such as I have had a few times. Didn't stop zapping until about 5 or 6 days had gone by, wouldn't you know it. lol

That's why I don't get too freaked out anymore if my soap is still zapping after more than a few days have gone by. Actually, I don't even check for zap anymore until a week or 2 after unmolding.


IrishLass :)
 
IrishLass said:
.............unless you have a stubborn, ornery (or maybe just a 'slow-as-molasses' to react) un-gelled batch of soap such as I have had a few times. Didn't stop zapping until about 5 or 6 days had gone by, wouldn't you know it. lol

That's why I don't get too freaked out anymore if my soap is still zapping after more than a few days have gone by. Actually, I don't even check for zap anymore until a week or 2 after unmolding.


IrishLass :)
Click to expand...

That's a good point. I can't say I've ever had one go past 24, but it can happen.
 
"...I don't even check for zap anymore until a week or 2 after unmolding...."

After intentionally making soap with 40% lye excess and finding it didn't zap after a few weeks of cure, I stopped worrying about zappity-ness. I test, yes, because I'm not interested in washing with a zappy soap, but I don't get too worried if one of my soap stays zappy a little longer than usual (most don't, but it sometimes happens); I just give it more time.
 

Similar threads

A
Pouring at emulsion
Replies
12
Views
479
ackosel
A
A
Ack! Kerblewy!
2
Replies
21
Views
533
ackosel
A
Joy Wolff
Newbee: issue with fragrance oil in hot process soap
Replies
3
Views
340
AliOop
AliOop
JutalakKhort
Is this called riced soap and is it safe to use?
Replies
2
Views
730
JutalakKhort
JutalakKhort
Oumsofia25
Eco enzyme soap
Replies
12
Views
2K
Oumsofia25
Oumsofia25

Latest posts

Back
Top