If price isn't including in the equation, I would say Majestic Mountain Sage. I've had more consistent winners from there than any other supplier. The quality is top drawer, their fragrance calc is spot on, and most of what I've used in the past sticks. I found a bar of their Green Cactus the other day that is so old I have no remembrance of when it was made. (Of course, at my age, I have the same problem with the bars on the curing rack right now. LOL Good thing I now use one of their Cure Card Sheets.