Hello. I have searched a lot of answers that kind of address this issue, but none discuss what might have happened with a recipe that has worked well in the past. Basic 3-oil soap. 9.4 oz Crisco, 6 oz olive, 6 oz coconut. 7 oz h2O, 3 oz lye, 1 oz fragrance. I have made this recipe a bunch of times. Reliable product. Produces not a super hard soap, but not super soft, either. I made the soap and was careful to get it to thin trace, because in the past, I have had it get too thick too fast. So thin trace. Loaf mold for 36 hours. It comes out of the mold, but it is pretty soft. Will it harden as the weeks go by? Is the thinner trace to blame here? I did add in a teaspoon of natural pigment mixed into a Tablespoon of Avocado oil, at the very end, to swirl. Did that cause this? Will this soap harden up? Thank you thank you for your help.