Got the new today that I finally did it and made a successful shave soap. This is the soft type, forget what it is called, poured in an 8 oz jar with enough space to lather it up. I gave it to a male wet shaver to test and was told today that it is fantastic. Kicks up a great cushion type lather, and he told me he did not have to re-apply it. I asked him if he thought it was good enough for market and he said absolutely. Yeah, 2 yrs I have been trying to make a nice shave soap. He also tested my harder puck, said it was nice, but not as nice as the softer one.