Is this OK?

[chibi-soap]

Hi Pundits,
I'm in the midst of making my Christmas soap. Batch 1 went pretty well, but batch 2, which was exactly the same recipe, but I forgot to put the salt and sugar in, behaved very differently.
It took forever to come to trace, and in the end, I put it in the molds at quite a light trace.
When I peeked under the towel keeping it warm, it looked completely gelled, whereas the first batch didn't gel around the edges (I think).

It was much stickier and softer when I unmolded it the next day and now, as you can see from the picture it is still soft with a greasy layer and a sort of translucent aspect to it.
Will it be OK, or should I ditch it?
First batch is on the left, second on the right.
View media item 2614

 

[atiz]

Hm, somehow I cannot see the picture.
Salt is known to accelerate a little bit, so the lack of salt could be responsible for slower trace. Not sure about the others since I cannot see the photo.

 

[lsg]

I would give it a chance to cure for several weeks.

 

[chibi-soap]

Hm, somehow I cannot see the picture.
Salt is known to accelerate a little bit, so the lack of salt could be responsible for slower trace. Not sure about the others since I cannot see the photo.

Let me try posting the picture again...
View media item 2614

I would give it a chance to cure for several weeks.

OK. Shall do!

 

[Arimara]

Are you using the [Upload a File] button at the bottom of the screen? That link is private.

 

[chibi-soap]

Are you using the [Upload a File] button at the bottom of the screen? That link is private.

Ah no, I inserted an image from my media collection.

 

[Obsidian]

its looks fine, just let it cure

 

[chibi-soap]

its looks fine, just let it cure

Thanks!

 

[atiz]

Looks like soap to me too Nice white bars!

 

[cmzaha]

Looks like soap to me. Let them cure