homesteaders
Well-Known Member
Here's an interesting study comparing Essential Oils, Extracts, and Methylparaben as preservatives. I'll post the link rather than the entire study.
Interesting Study: Essential Oils & Extracts as Preservatives
- Thread starter homesteaders
- Start date
Help Support Soapmaking Forum:
These tests were done in the lab under controlled conditions. This kind of study is a useful screening tool, but I disagree their result "...shows that tested extracts and essential oils could replace use of methylparaben..." Positive results -- especially those in a screening type of study -- are not proof of efficacy.
This overstatement should have been criticized by their peer reviewers. Trained researchers should look at the actual results, however, not the spin these authors wanted to put on their results. The problems will occur if everyday people take this kind of comment as literal truth and run wild with it.
This overstatement should have been criticized by their peer reviewers. Trained researchers should look at the actual results, however, not the spin these authors wanted to put on their results. The problems will occur if everyday people take this kind of comment as literal truth and run wild with it.
homesteaders
Well-Known Member
Earlier in the report, it acknowledges that the study was done in a lab, and that other factors come into play when other ingredients are used in different cosmetics. The study notes that most allergic reactions are from the preservatives, and this was an early study to find safe and effective alternatives with a lower risk of allergic reactions. My take away on this was that many essential oils and extracts have excellent antimicrobial properties, and are well worth further study, especially since the lab results were so much more impressive than methylparaben. Some of the oils mentioned were not oils most would want or could tolerate in a lotion. But, this study is a great starting point for further testing.
I am one that is allergic to many Essential oils and not synthetics. If it grows outside I am very suspectable to being allergic.
homesteaders
Well-Known Member
Having that problem would turn my life upside down. So sorry you have to deal with that. I am just the opposite.
Similar threads
