I am likely to get jumped on for this, but on forums like this no one is going to give anyone anything, other than praise, no matter what the end product looks like.
I was sent this fugly bar of soap from a professional shop, the pic is likely still in the review area someplace, and people had no trouble telling me it was ugly, nasty, and, according to a couple, looked like something a 6 year old would make. I've seen some closely resembling bars since that time and no one has anything other than extensive words of praise for them.
I think, at times, people get too caught up in not potential hurting someone that they withhold what they really, truly think. I've been a victim of this (not here) before, too. I would have rather had the truth from the beginning, than had a bunch of untruths thrown at me. A teenager's opinion shouldn't be dismissed purely on the basis that he or she did not like the design, and an adult shouldn't be called rude, for not liking it, either.
I think the scent sounds lovely, but I don't think the rebatch looks that great to me. It kind of reminds me of melted concrete or something. Now, that doesn't mean I'm saying "ewww! Never soap again! Awful!" because I'm not. This particular batch just is not aesthetically appealing to me. That's all.