Ok. Total noob here. This is my first colored soap. Half of it ended up on the floor when I spilled it everywhere. Needless to say, after that fiasco, I wasn't expecting much. If I were to sell this (which I wouldn't as its a mess) I would market it as psychedelic hippie soap. Almost looks like a mushroom Compared to my first uncolored batch Even though the results were not what I wanted, I had fun doing it and look forward to making more. The colored stuff is so much softer than the non colored stuff. Non colored was 45% lard and colored is 48% lard. Weird as I thought more lard would make it harder? I did superfat the colored 1% more. Meh, I am learning as I go.