I've only used orange EO once in CP and had exactly exactly the same experience.
However, the soap I made in February with this Orange and Ginger FO is still going strong. It's not a super-juicy orange scent, but it's definitely orange. And it's one of my favourite fragrances, for sure!
Funny, as I'm re-reading the reviews for this soap, people say it's weak and fades....it's my STRONGEST fragrance by far, out of perhaps 15-18 batches. Strange....
