Seems like it took forever to find the prefect Christmas fragrances, but I ended up with Bayberry fo in the bottom, Cinnamon eo in the top layer, and oxides for color. Oh, and Gold Mica on top. I really like the smell of these. Also, since I was running out of time I made these with the hp crock pot method and added 1 t sugar to the lye water and increased the water by 5%. Thanks to suggestions I learned from DragonQueenHHP She was right, It made them easy to work with and look smooth like cp soap!