Beer Soap?

Soapmaking Forum

Help Support Soapmaking Forum:

jcandleattic

Well-Known Member
Joined
Jun 13, 2008
Messages
4,115
Reaction score
3,912
Location
Stuck in my head
You probably want to add colorant bc the color of the beer will go tan regardless of the color of the beer
I dont' find this to be true. I've used Guinness in soap (a very dark stout) with no real colorant, and my soap was slightly ecru. I think it has a lot to do with if you gel your soap, and the oils used.

I'm one of those that don't simmer the alcohol out of my beer. I just let it sit open for a few hours to a day so it will go flat, add a pinch of salt (this will help it go flat) soap at room temp and either let it sit uncovered on the counter, or throw it in the fridge - depending on the fragrance used. My beer and milk soaps are the only soaps I try to discourage gel in because they do tend to heat.
By not simmering out the alcohol my soap does get thicker faster, but it's nothing I'm not used to or not prepared for, so it's just not a problem for me.
 

Gryphonisle

Member
Joined
Jul 22, 2019
Messages
22
Reaction score
13
Location
San Francisco
I made my beer soap this weekend, using a Presidio Pale Ale—-and as one post predicted, it came out an off white. Hmmph! Nice yeasty smell on cutting. I set the beer out to de-carbonate on wednesday and froze it Friday night, making the soap Saturday night. Any suggestions for getting a darker, perhaps more of an amber colored bar if a dark beer (like a bock) wouldn’t necessarily make a darker shade, again amber?

I dont' find this to be true. I've used Guinness in soap (a very dark stout) with no real colorant, and my soap was slightly ecru. I think it has a lot to do with if you gel your soap, and the oils used.

I'm one of those that don't simmer the alcohol out of my beer. I just let it sit open for a few hours to a day so it will go flat, add a pinch of salt (this will help it go flat) soap at room temp and either let it sit uncovered on the counter, or throw it in the fridge - depending on the fragrance used. My beer and milk soaps are the only soaps I try to discourage gel in because they do tend to heat.
By not simmering out the alcohol my soap does get thicker faster, but it's nothing I'm not used to or not prepared for, so it's just not a problem for me.
I didn’t wrap it to encourage gel either, but more because it didn’t have any color to “pop” but that is another consideration you gave! It certainly thickened quickly! It hadn’t even reached emulsion when the lower part of the bowl was thickening—-I had to push the blending in order to ensure the oils were mixed, and hoped it wouldn’t seize. It didn’t.
 
Last edited by a moderator:

DeeAnna

Well-Known Member
Joined
Feb 20, 2013
Messages
14,328
Reaction score
21,967
Location
USA
"...Any suggestions for getting a darker, perhaps more of an amber colored bar if a dark beer (like a bock) wouldn’t necessarily make a darker shade, again amber?..."

If you don't like the color the beer is giving you, then it's time to look at adding other colorants to get what you want. Lots of options there depending on what color direction you want to go. Cocoa powder, annatto infused oil, micas, yellow and/or red iron oxide ........
 
A

amd

Like with other types of cooking, I think that the best use of beer in the recipe is for the cook to drink the beer and it not be wasted in the recipe. :)
I have this conversation often with my husband and I remind him that on my favorite things list, soap and beer are 1st and 2nd, and he is only 3rd, so his opinion doesn't matter. If the soap is used and enjoyed I don't consider it wasted. My wholesale accounts would also agree, it sells well for them and has a good following.
 

Zen Pretzel

Member
Joined
Dec 7, 2019
Messages
19
Reaction score
21
Location
Canada
I've also started playing with the beer soaps. A tall boy can is the perfect amount. After boiling off the alcohol, I just needed to add a tiny bit of water. I made soap with Guinness today. In the future, I plan on making beer using Corona, to test a light beer, Rickards Red to use a red beer and Labbatt Blue, as a control pilsner beer for comparison. No fragrances or anything. Just replacing water for beer and keeping everything else the same.
 
Joined
Jan 9, 2020
Messages
160
Reaction score
332
Location
New Jersey
I've also started playing with the beer soaps. A tall boy can is the perfect amount. After boiling off the alcohol, I just needed to add a tiny bit of water. I made soap with Guinness today. In the future, I plan on making beer using Corona, to test a light beer, Rickards Red to use a red beer and Labbatt Blue, as a control pilsner beer for comparison. No fragrances or anything. Just replacing water for beer and keeping everything else the same.
What does the beer do in the soap? Does it make the skin softer? Is it moisturizing, etc.? since FO's are added, I imagine it doesn't smell like beer.
 

Zen Pretzel

Member
Joined
Dec 7, 2019
Messages
19
Reaction score
21
Location
Canada
What does the beer do in the soap? Does it make the skin softer? Is it moisturizing, etc.? since FO's are added, I imagine it doesn't smell like beer.
From what I've been able to research, the beer doesn't add a whole lot to the soap. There are some minor qualities that get affected when beer is used, along with a slight odor, but I'm making this more for the novelty factor. Beer soaps are big sellers for a lot of soapmakers, so it's something I want to research. As for the fragrances, I'm not adding any FO to my beer soaps at this time until I'm more comfortable making them. Perhaps others know some good fragrances to add to their beer soap.
 

LittleBlackHeart

New Member
Joined
Feb 19, 2019
Messages
1
Reaction score
1
Location
Utah
First time posting but figured this is one I can I can chime in on. Oddly enough I have made almost all my soaps out of beer and I'm 3 years into making at about 40 batches total. Using beer just happened due to my Father in law being a big home brewer and when he moved we got about 5 boxes of beer and these were the not great beers...drinkable but not his best work. So I started using them in making soaps. I do use scents, mostly EO's, that would go with the type of beer. Like a Grapefruit Hefeweizen soap, etc. I just boiled Lime a rita to try a salt soap and just did a Cranberry Ginger Shandy bar. I use a standard recipe and switch beer for water. I've found more issues with trace due to fragrances than the beer. I was also using a bit more Castor oil as I was under the impression that it added to lather until recently learning it's just a stabilizer so my last two batches I put it way low. Haven't got to test those yet so we'll see difference once they're done.
 

DeeAnna

Well-Known Member
Joined
Feb 20, 2013
Messages
14,328
Reaction score
21,967
Location
USA
What does the beer do in the soap? Does it make the skin softer? Is it moisturizing, etc.? since FO's are added, I imagine it doesn't smell like beer.

I shared my perspective on this in Post #4 in this thread. The short answer is beer increases the amount of lather. And it's just fun to use.

I'm sipping on a Blue Moon as I write this -- not every beer in my house gets turned into soap, just to relieve @CathyB 's mind. ;)
 

math ace

Well-Known Member
Joined
Nov 30, 2018
Messages
432
Reaction score
343
Location
Jacksonville, FL
IMG_20200216_122026630.jpg IMG_20200216_230441515.jpg

I'm giving beer soap a try tomorrow! Hoping for great bubbles.
 
Joined
Mar 12, 2019
Messages
283
Reaction score
555
Location
Israel
When I started making beer soap, I thought I needed a fragrance that "matched" the beer. Now I just use any fragrance because I'm doing it for the lather. I've made lavender apricot FO beer soap, lime beer soap, etc.
 

Zen Pretzel

Member
Joined
Dec 7, 2019
Messages
19
Reaction score
21
Location
Canada
When I started making beer soap, I thought I needed a fragrance that "matched" the beer. Now I just use any fragrance because I'm doing it for the lather. I've made lavender apricot FO beer soap, lime beer soap, etc.
Cool. So far I've made beer soap using Guinness and another batch using a red beer. Today I'm going to make a beer soap using Corona. I wasn't planning on adding any fragrances, but adding a lime scent to a Corona bar of soap sounds like a great idea.
 
Joined
Jan 9, 2020
Messages
160
Reaction score
332
Location
New Jersey
First time posting but figured this is one I can I can chime in on. Oddly enough I have made almost all my soaps out of beer and I'm 3 years into making at about 40 batches total. Using beer just happened due to my Father in law being a big home brewer and when he moved we got about 5 boxes of beer and these were the not great beers...drinkable but not his best work. So I started using them in making soaps. I do use scents, mostly EO's, that would go with the type of beer. Like a Grapefruit Hefeweizen soap, etc. I just boiled Lime a rita to try a salt soap and just did a Cranberry Ginger Shandy bar. I use a standard recipe and switch beer for water. I've found more issues with trace due to fragrances than the beer. I was also using a bit more Castor oil as I was under the impression that it added to lather until recently learning it's just a stabilizer so my last two batches I put it way low. Haven't got to test those yet so we'll see difference once they're done.
I have no beer in my house and no beer drinkers. No, we're not tea-tollers, just not beer. Picnic weather is coming up. Maybe I'll grab a beer at one of the cookouts and try it in the future.
 
Joined
Nov 4, 2019
Messages
525
Reaction score
780
Location
Aylett, VA, USA
I've made beer & hard cider soaps. There are a lot of local breweries in our area, so it's fun to make the soap from the local establishments. My "never met a stranger" daughter is now wanting to pitch sales of these soaps in the tasting rooms of these breweries. We'll see what happens, but I guess I better get cracking as I have only been making 20 oz batches of these soaps.
 
Joined
Jan 31, 2020
Messages
10
Reaction score
2
Location
Melbourne
I have some homemade cider which is just undrinkable could I use this instead of beer? It's a natural cider of apples, yeast and a little extra apple juice at the end of processing? If so does anyone has a good cider soap recipe I can experiment with :) please
 
Top