Sorry to jump in, but was the Lye a little short in the recipe, (MMS says 7.30oz). I know it's not that much different, but scales differ etc and this MAY have contributed to the problem.
Be gentle this is my first post :)
:D Hello, I've been soaping for a few years now and am always eager to learn more, which is how I came across this lovely site. I am researching adding honey to soaps before I take the plunge!