I thought I would clarify on how thick my soap batter was for this, I said earlier to make sure it is not too thick but really you need to stick blend just until everything is emulsified. I hope to see how everyone does who tries it.
Sangria is red but when I added the lye it turned green then orange then to a reddish brown. Now it is just brown and is darker today than it was yesterday.
I really like how this came out and I am very surprised that the white part of the soap is the natural color of the beer, usually it is brown so I will be using the same brand again when I want a white color, now if I could make my black really black and not gray.
I used a a flat stick about half an inch wide to make the swirl after splitting the batter in 2 equal parts and used a center divider in the mold. I moved it back and forth across the two colors and then up and down a few times and that is it. Make sure your batter is not too thick.
I have not tried any of the ones you list but I love Stud and Blue Agave for men and others that are strong are Champagne Pomegranate, China Rain and I love their Oatmeal Milk and Honey, Plumeria is really nice once it cures a little.
This beer I used was a dark beer strong smell, the first beer soap I made I used Miller beer and it is fine I only smell the FO I scented it with and not the beer.