Blue, I'll tell you a neat trick that I have done on a few occasions.
You can shred the batch (either batch) and add them in equal portions to a new batch that compliments them.
Example: For the batch that is too cleansing: Grate it up and add it in equal amounts to a batch that has little or no "cleansing" oils. It could be, say, palm, shortening, canola, etc. And you add up to 50/50 grated soap with the same weight of the new recipe oils. (did that make sense???) In other words, if your new soap oils weigh 30 oz. total, then you need no more than 30 oz. of grated soap to add to that recipe (you don't include the water weight of the new soap in your figuring of how much grated soap to use).
I've used this option for a number of "not right" batches over the years, and it works so well, plus the final soap has a really cool look, especially is your shreds are a contrasting color than the new soap. Some folks call it "confetti soap".
Add the shreds to the new soap at trace, just stir them in and pour. Gel as usual.