Back in my quest to make a longer lasting lathering salt bar I basically failed to come up with a long lasting lathering salt bar, keeping in mind I have been making salt bars since I started soaping 8 yrs ago. Well I just took one out to try again, which was made in 10/2014 and it lathers !! The other bubble killer was a small percentage of DS which I often use in my salt mix, but with the added coco butter it was a bubble killer, and felt a bit waxy. This bar no longer feels waxy and bubbles good using a bath pouf or it should bubble decently on a man with more body hair. After I had let them originally age for 6 months I just put them away to forget about them. After a year I ground up most of the batch and added them to a salty confetti bar but kept 4 of them.